James Tarkowski

Key strength: Aerial dominance

Defensive anchor

At 33 years old and anchoring Everton's defense from 8th place in the Premier League, James Tarkowski has become the immovable foundation Sean Dyche's side cannot function without. The England international has played every single minute of the campaign—270 across 3 matches—proving that age has only sharpened his defensive instincts. While his stat sheet reads modestly (0 goals, 1 assist, 4 yellow cards), Tarkowski's true worth transcends numbers. With defensive attributes rated at 82 and imposing physicality at 79, he dominates aerial duels and organizes the backline with authority. His commanding presence alongside young defensive partner Jarrad Branthwaite provides the stability Everton desperately needs. Valued at €9 million and contracted through 2028, this old-school centre-back wears the number 6 shirt with the grit and consistency that defines his era. For a club in perpetual transition, Tarkowski is the reliable constant—winning headers, making tackles, and ensuring Everton remain competitive in the top flight. His leadership, both vocal and through example, gives the midfield freedom to express themselves.