John Stones

Key strength: Aerial dominance

Defensive anchor

At Manchester City, the story of John Stones has taken an unexpected turn. While the defending champions sit proudly in 2nd place, the 31-year-old England international finds himself navigating a campaign marked by frustrating scarcity rather than silverware-chasing triumph. With just 17 appearances and 996 minutes under his belt this season, Stones has been relegated to the periphery of Pep Guardiola's plans—a stark contrast to his once-unassailable status as the team's defensive anchor. His solitary goal from limited opportunities barely scratches the surface of what he offers: exceptional passing range, aerial dominance, and that rare ability to stride confidently into midfield to dismantle opposition presses with surgical precision. Yet the competition is ferocious. The £18 million-rated centre-back now battles not just persistent fitness concerns, but the meteoric rise of Josko Gvardiol and the formidable presence of Rúben Dias—both rated 78 alongside him. As City's star-studded squad rotates seamlessly, Stones faces a crucible of resilience. His redemption arc demands not just the composure that defined his prime, but the consistency that has eluded him. For a defender whose cerebral approach once made him Guardiola's perfect soldier, the challenge is clear: prove that body and quality can finally align.