Séamus Coleman

Key strength: Pace and recovery

Overlapping full-back

In an era of fleeting loyalty and astronomical wages, Séamus Coleman stands as a monument to what football used to be—and perhaps still should be. At 37, Everton's Irish captain patrols the right flank with the same determination that saw him signed from Sligo Rovers for a paltry €500,000 back in 2009. Eighth in the table after a mixed run of form (LWDDW in their last five), the Toffees find themselves in familiar mid-table territory, yet Coleman's presence provides intangible value no statistic captures. With 8 appearances and 360 minutes this season, his output reads modestly—zero goals, zero assists—but his 78 defending rating and leadership continue to steady a dressing room featuring talents like James Garner and Jack Grealish. That 75 passing rating still unlocks attacks from deep, while his mentorship of younger teammates proves priceless. A €500,000 market value is laughable for a man whose contract runs until 2026, defying both Father Time and football's obsession with youth. Coleman isn't just playing—he's preserving a dying art: the one-club warrior.